Valuation guide
Should you pay for an online business's potential?
Almost every listing has a paragraph on growth opportunities: prices that have never been raised, a social channel nobody has started, an email list that is never mailed, a feature customers keep asking for. Some of it is true. Very little of it is something the seller has done, and the price you agree is paid for what the seller has done.
What a sold multiple is actually a multiple of
A profit multiple is the sale price divided by the profit the business earned over the trailing year. It describes what buyers paid for income that already existed. Every sale behind a published median had its own list of opportunities, and the buyers already weighed them — the multiple is what was left after they did. So the multiple already contains the market's view of how much an unproven opportunity is worth, and adding a premium for the same kind of opportunity on top of it counts it twice. See what a profit multiple means.
There is also a simple ownership argument. If raising prices would add income, the buyer is the one who will raise them, take the risk that customers leave, and do the work. Paying the seller in advance for that result means paying for your own effort, and still carrying the chance it does not work.
Common kinds of potential, and how solid each is
- "Prices haven't been raised in years." Often real, and among the cheaper tests a new owner can run. But the price may be low for a reason — a competitor, a price-sensitive audience, customers who stay only because it is cheap. It is untested until it is tested.
- "No marketing has ever been done." Sometimes it means the business grew on its own. Sometimes it means the seller tried and stopped. Ask which, and ask for the numbers if any campaign was run. Paid traffic changes the cost base; see businesses that run on paid ads.
- "The email list is never mailed." A list that has not heard from the sender in a year often performs far worse than its size suggests when it is finally used. See valuing an email list.
- "Customers are asking for feature X." Building it costs money or time, and in software it may sit on code that is hard to change; see technical debt.
- "It could rank for far more keywords." Plausible for most content sites, and not something anyone controls. See businesses that depend on search traffic.
- "The owner only works two hours a week on it." Not upside, but often presented next to it. It describes the seller's cost of running the business, which may not be yours; see owner-dependent businesses.
When paying for some of it is fair
Not all potential is speculation. The case for paying something extra is strongest when the result has already started to show in the figures, rather than in the description:
- The change is already made and working. A price rise three months ago, with the months since at the new level and customers still there, is no longer potential — it is recent income. The question becomes how much of a year to credit it with; see valuing a growing business.
- An asset is clearly underused and transfers whole. A strong domain, a trademark or a large engaged audience has a value of its own that does not depend on the seller's plans. It still has to be checked, not taken from the listing.
- Competition for the deal. When several buyers want the same business, one of them may agree to pay for upside to win it. That is a choice about winning, not evidence the upside is real.
Keeping upside out of the base price
- Price on trailing profit you have verified. Do the checks in verifying a seller's revenue and profit first; potential is discussed after the base is agreed, not instead of it.
- If you pay for upside, tie it to the upside. An earn-out — part of the price paid later, only if a stated figure is reached — puts the risk where the claim came from. On small deals it adds tracking and room for disagreement, so it needs a clear, measurable target. See what a headline sale price includes.
- Write down the plan the price assumes. If you do decide to pay above the trailing figure, note which opportunity it is for and what result would justify it. It turns a vague premium into something you can check yourself against later.
- Treat a long opportunity list with a short history carefully. A young business sold mostly on what it could become is priced on very little evidence; see valuing a business less than a year old.
What our sold data shows — and what it cannot
Figures read from /api/stats when this page loads.
The figures below are what buyers actually paid, relative to the trailing profit the source stated. We do not record each listing's growth story, so we cannot separate sales that were pitched on potential from those that were not; the medians include both. What the table does show is the range buyers paid for income that already existed, which is the base any premium for potential would sit on.
| Asset type | Comps with stated profit | Median × profit | Median stated annual profit | Middle-half sold price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading live figures from /api/stats… | ||||
The first two columns cover every non-demo sold deal of that type with a stated profit. The median profit and the middle-half price (25th to 75th percentile) are measured over the paid report's window — the most recent 200 priced sales of that type — on the profit basis. A dash means we hold fewer than five comparables on that basis and publish nothing.
Getting a range instead of a number
Put the verified trailing profit into the calculator to see what comparable sales paid for income of that size. If a seller's asking price only makes sense on a projection, the gap between their number and that range is the amount they are asking you to pay for potential. The paid report adds public-web comparables, a risk register and questions to put to the seller.
Related: asking price vs sold price · making an offer · red flags in a listing · methodology · all valuation guides