Buyer's guide
Red flags in an online business listing, and what to ask about each
A listing is written to sell. Most sellers are honest, but a listing still shows the business at its best, and the things that should lower your price are rarely in the headline. These are the signs worth noticing before you make an offer, sorted by where they show up.
A flag is a question, not a verdict
Nothing below means a business is a bad buy on its own. Each one is a reason to ask something specific, and the answer decides whether it costs you anything. A seller who answers plainly and with records has usually removed the flag; one who cannot, or will not, has told you something more useful than the listing did. Ask in writing, so the answers can become part of the deal.
Flags in the numbers
- Earnings shown only as a monthly average, or a short recent stretch annualised. Ask for twelve months, month by month. Monthly vs annual multiples explains how a multiple quoted on the wrong period can look cheap.
- Screenshots in place of access. Ask for read-only access to the payment processor, store, ad and affiliate dashboards, and match payouts to bank deposits. How to verify a seller's revenue and profit walks through it.
- Large add-backs. Owner pay, "one-off" costs and personal expenses added back can be legitimate, or they can be most of the profit. Ask for each one itemised with its evidence — see seller's discretionary earnings.
- A sharp recent rise or fall. Ask what caused it and whether it repeats. Growing and declining businesses are priced differently, and a seasonal peak can pass for either — see seasonal businesses.
- Less than a year of history. Ask for everything since launch; there may not be a full year to price on. Valuing a business less than a year old covers what to do instead.
- A multiple quoted without saying of what. Ask whether it is a multiple of profit or revenue, over which period, and before or after the owner's time. What a profit multiple actually means sets out the difference.
Flags in the business
- One source of traffic, one platform or one customer. Ask for revenue and traffic split by source. See platform dependence and concentrated revenue.
- The seller is the product. If customers come for the seller's name, face or voice, ask what happens when they leave. Valuing an owner-dependent business covers costing the replacement.
- Unlisted helpers. Ask who else does work in the business — contractors, agencies, a partner — whether they are paid in the stated costs, and whether they will stay.
- Accounts in someone else's name. Ask which domains, stores, ad accounts, supplier and affiliate accounts can actually be handed over. Transferring an online business after the sale has the list; affiliate income is a common case where they cannot.
- Stock not counted. For a store, ask whether inventory is in the price, at what value and counted when. See valuing an online store with inventory.
Flags in how the sale is run
- Pressure to decide quickly. A real competing offer can exist, but so can a manufactured one. Ask for the time you need to verify the numbers; a sound business usually survives a week of checking.
- Payment outside escrow or a marketplace's own process. Ask why. Paying a stranger directly for a business you cannot yet control leaves you little recourse if the handover fails — how to buy a small online business covers the usual sequence.
- An asking price justified by a rule of thumb. "These sell for three times profit" is not evidence. Ask which sold deals the price is based on. Valuation rules of thumb explains why they mislead, and asking price vs sold price why a listing price is not a sale.
- Questions that go unanswered. Silence on a specific question is an answer. Note it, and price or walk accordingly.
Checking the asking price against sold deals
Figures read from /api/stats when this page loads.
The one flag our data can test directly is the price. Divide the asking price by the profit you have verified — not the profit in the listing — and compare it with what businesses of the same type actually sold for. The table shows how many sold comparables we hold for each type and their median profit multiple; a median is withheld below five comparables rather than estimated.
| Asset type | Sold deals tracked | Comps with stated profit | Median × profit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loading live figures from /api/stats… | |||
Counts cover every non-demo sold deal of that type. A median across a whole asset type mixes businesses of very different sizes, and in some types it sits below 1× because small auction listings often state a profit the sale price did not bear out — we publish those sales as they happened. Read a low median as a floor rather than a fair price; what a profit multiple actually means explains why. The calculator says so when it applies, and warns when the comps are much larger or smaller than the business you enter.
Getting a range instead of a number
Once the flags are settled and the profit is one you trust, give it to the calculator: it compares it with the sold comps we hold and shows how many there were. The paid report adds public-web comparables, a risk register and questions to put to the seller.
Related: how to make an offer on an online business · why similar businesses sell for different prices · methodology · all valuation guides