Valuation guide · explainer
What a headline sale price actually includes
"Sold for $18.95 million" is a sentence about a payment that never happened. The number is real, the deal is real, and no one wrote a cheque for it — it is four different promises added together, one of which was never paid at all. This is the ordinary shape of an acquisition headline, and it is why a comp built from headlines runs high.
A headline is a total, and a total hides its parts
Almost any reported deal value is a sum of components that are not worth the same thing to the person receiving them. Money at closing is money. Money promised over three years is money minus the risk the buyer stops paying. Money that arrives only if the business hits targets after the founder has left is not a payment at all — it is an option the buyer wrote and the seller now holds.
When those are summed into one figure and printed as the price, the resulting number is a ceiling: the most that could ever be paid, under the best case for every contingent part. Treat it as the price and every multiple you derive from it is high by however much of the total never landed.
Three reported deals, taken apart
Publicly reported deals, each linked to the report that states the terms.
| Reported as | Cash at closing | Fixed but deferred | Contingent | Outside the price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BattlBox — $18.95M | $10.25M | $1.5M over 3 years | up to $7.2M earn-out | — |
| Fully Booked VA — $180,000 | — | 36 × $5,000, plus a balloon interest payment | — | — |
| Necklow — $380,000 | $380,000 | — | — | $30,000 for remaining inventory |
Terms as stated by They Got Acquired in each linked report (read 2026-09-05). Three headlines, three completely different things. BattlBox's $18.95M is a ceiling: $10.25M of it was paid at closing, and $7.2M of it was an earn-out the buyer owed only if the business hit targets over the following three years. Fully Booked VA's $180,000 is a real, fixed price that arrives as thirty-six monthly payments. Necklow's $380,000 is the business; the $30,000 that makes the "total transaction" $410,000 bought the pillows in the warehouse.
What each component is worth
- Cash at closing. The only part that is certainly paid. If you compare one number across deals, compare this one.
- Fixed deferred payments and seller financing. A real price, paid late. The amount is not in doubt, but the seller now carries the buyer's credit risk for the whole term — a business that fails in year two takes the rest of the payments with it. Discount for time and for that risk, but do not discount it to zero: it is a price.
- Earn-outs and performance-tied payments. Contingent, and usually contingent on the period after the seller loses control of the business. "Up to" is doing all the work in these clauses. The honest way to carry an earn-out into a valuation is at zero, and to be pleased later.
- Stock or shares in the buyer. Priced at the announcement, worth whatever it is worth when it vests and can be sold — which for a private buyer may be never.
- Inventory and working capital. Not a valuation of the business at all. It is a reimbursement for assets that were already owned, and folding it into the headline inflates the multiple against profit that inventory did not generate.
- Holdbacks and escrow. Part of the price, withheld against warranties. Ask how much and for how long — it is the difference between a price and a price with a deductible.
The rule we publish under
This is not a hypothetical problem for us; it decides what goes in the database. Our rule has three parts, and it is deliberately strict:
- A total that folds in a contingent component is a cap, not a price — we skip it. An earn-out expressed as a ceiling, a performance-tied payment, or performance-dependent shares all disqualify the headline. A headline like BattlBox's is not ingested at $18.95M, and not ingested at $10.25M either, because that is not the figure the source asserts as the price.
- A fixed deferred or instalment total is a price — we publish it. Deferred is not contingent. Fully Booked VA at $180,000, paid over thirty-six months, is a sold comp.
- A realized total, attributed to a primary source, is a price — we publish it. Where a filing or a party states what was actually paid once the contingent parts resolved, that is a fact about a completed payment rather than a ceiling.
One thing we never do is arithmetic on the seller's behalf. Where a report states a cash figure and an open-ended earn-out and no total, we do not add them, and we do not quietly ingest the cash figure as the price — the source has not asserted a price, so there isn't one to record. The cost of that strictness is rows we walk away from; the benefit is that a multiple computed from our data is computed from money that changed hands.
Live from /api/stats. What survives the rule, in other words. Full sourcing
standards are in the methodology.
Five questions that take a headline apart
Whether you are reading a press announcement, a broker's track record, or the number a seller quotes you across a table, the same five questions resolve it:
- How much was paid on the day the deal closed?
- What is fixed but unpaid, over what term, and secured by what?
- What is contingent, on which targets, measured by whom, and who runs the business while those targets are being measured?
- What is in shares — of what, valued when, saleable when?
- What in that total was inventory, cash left in the business, or another asset that was already owned?
Then price it against sales that state their terms
Once you can take a headline apart, the rest of the comps discipline follows: an asking price is not a sale (why the gap exists), a sale is only a comp if it matches your business on size and basis as well as category (what makes a sold comp comparable), and the multiple that comes out means what its denominator means (what a profit multiple actually means).
what makes a sold comp comparable · sub-$100k diligence checklist · what small online businesses sell for · all valuation guides